Beyonce all time rank

Hmm, you said "don't bring up thievery or stealing"

Then she ranks no where with these women. Thievery and stealing is her foundation. Of these three women, the ONLY one she MIGHT out rank would be Alicia, that's only cuz she did more visual sh** than Alicia, more shuckin' and jiving across the stage,her stan base really like the visuals, but unlike Alicia's music there is no substance to any of Beyonce's music, it's forgettable. And, Alicia has an actual talent, she can play the hell outta that piano. She doesn't even rank anywhere with Whitney and Janet, I don't even have to go there.
Beyonce out rank people like Keyshia Cole, or K. Michelle, but the three women you mentioned, nah she really cant touch them, unless she resorts to the thievery and theft otherwise.....there's really nothing. JMHO

Beytlejuice vs alicia keys
- Alicia is a trained musician, Bey isn't. Alicia writes songs as well as composes. Bey? *no comment, since we can't mention stealing*

- Vocally they've both aged pretty bad, though the transition seemed to happen a lot earlier with Alicia. She struggled to sing "Fallin'" in the original key by the time she started promoting her first album.


Beytlejuice vs Whitney

- Even post prime I'd still rather listen to Whitney than Bey. Her diction and control continued to be very good even as her range became more limited. When Whitney was in her prime there was no one who could compare, period. I don't know when would be considerd Bey's prime vocally but I can say that Whitney's first album >>>> DIL and her last recorded album > any of the singles I've heard from Beyonce
- The production value and musical arrangements are generally better in Whitney's singles than Beyonce's. Even when she departed from her usual r&b/pop and did something a little different (e.g., "Queen of the Night". "My  Love is Your Love", "If I Told You That") the music was still tailored to stand up to and compliment her voice.



Beytlejuice vs Janet
- Bey's voice is stronger but I prefer Janet's tone. Her voice is naturally sweet and softly melodic, Bey's voice is louder and isnt' very sweet without help. I guess Bey may have had a larger octave range at some point but that may have changed.
- Janet has a better ear for layering background vocals and she does a better job of harmonizing with herself. One thing that Bey has copied from JJ and MJ but mastered is the perfect layering. Any time I've heard Bey's music the background vocals always sounded slightly off to me.
- Janet write, co-writes, and co-arranges a lot of her music
- The instrumentals alone from the prime of Janet's career (RN and Janet) are far superior to anything I've heard from Bey. Some of the songs were on-trend without becoming disposable and they can still be considered good music decades after the fact. Janet and her team have done a better job of crafting really good music instead of just tacking a song on to a hot beat.

^^I think I cought that right, lol! I was just randomly thinking when those MET Gala pics came out that; "hmm I hope she bathed her ass before she went all comando in that MET Gala get-up." Otherwise it would be a funky situation, like, seriously, no drawers, no nothing underneath??.. eew! I heard that we'd be totally surprised to know who actually showered before an event or a ball as far as calebrities, but I hope she did. I know me. ..I can't even go to the store without a shower, I gotta smell good at ALL times! My hubby is always like, "you must be one of the cleanest women on earth!" I told him, you should be happy, ha, I won't repeat his response since it's x-rated! Lol...lmao!

But yall hv a good night, and I might not be on after today, but enjoy your one day of the yr for mothers day to all that apply. Cuz I am!

Goodnight!

missy I love how u broke, it down but in my opinion they all suck

Beyonce's voice was never sweet to me. When she does other mainstream melodic sings besides irreplaceable and maybe if i were a boy, she lacks emotion, soul, depth, her music hardly ever has soul to me. She could never amount to what the other ladies mentioned before has. Its one thing to to try and be versatile and to appeal to different audiences but its another to be genuine with it.

Her music catalog to me overall just lacks the soul. But then thats what happens when you steal music and video concepts. And then again that what happens when you sell it to be where the upper echelons is.